Ethnic Cleansing of the XVth–XVIIth Centuries in Eastern Ukraine Territories (On the Issue of Sources of Rashist Praxis)

Author

Balushok Vasyl

a Ph.D. in History, a senior research fellow at the Ukrainian Ethnological Centre Department of the M. Rylskyi Institute of Art Studies, Folkloristics and Ethnology of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine (Kyiv, Ukraine).

ORCID ID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1362-8270

Ethnic Cleansing of the XVth–XVIIth Centuries
in Eastern Ukraine Territories (On the Issue of Sources of Rashist Praxis)

Abstract

The article deals with how Muscovy, in the XVth – early to mid-XVIIth centuries, changed the ethnic composition of the Siverian Lands and the Upper Oka Principalities – the then eastern territories of Rus-Ukraine – due to large-scale ethnic cleansing and their subsequent settlement by Muscovites. It is shown how, in the course of expansionist practices at the dawn of the Russian Empire formation, modern methods of hybrid war arose, with its propaganda, seizure of territories, looting, extermination and deportation of people.

There is an analysis of the insufficiently researched events of the late XVth to early XVIIth centuries in eastern Rus-Ukraine, in the Siverian Lands and on its eastern border – in the Upper Oka Principalities. These territories, which, along with other Ukrainian lands, previously belonged to the Grand Duchy of Lithuania and were occupied by Muscovy in the course of two wars, were inhabited by Sevryuks and minor communities – Mtsenskians, Lyubuchans, Kozelskians and others. The article’s task is to trace the rhetoric of Moscow’s ruling circles with regard to substantiating the imperial expansion, as well as to study actions of the conquerors from the point of view of identifying their ethnic component, including ethnic cleansing carried out by them. Sources of the study are ambassadorial documents, chronicles, memoirs and diaries of foreigners. Methodology of this historical and anthropological investigation includes achievements of scholars in studying ethnocentric conceptions (Justin Stagl, Anthony Smith, Oleksiy Tolochko) and the behavior of war people in pre-modern times (Philippe Contamine, Natalia Yakovenko). Result. During Muscovite-Lithuanian wars, with the first of which (1486–1494) undeclared, Moscow, for justifying its actions, widely used extensively deception and information sabotage (accusations of intimidating Orthodoxy, etc.), statements about the alleged patrimonial right to the former Ancient Rus lands. Emphasis is placed on the relationship between the conquerors and the local population, in which the own-alien contraposition is displayed. Attention is drawn to the cruel, even for the Middle Ages, Muscovite practices in relation to aborigines: looting, terror, murders, taking prisoners, and even enticement of local princes to their side, annexation and colonization of lands. During the second war (1500–1503), only the lands of the princes, whom Moscow lured to its side by lavish promises and deception, escaped plunder.  After the annexation of Sivershchyna, Muscovites started to populate these territories on a mass scale, which, along with the oppression of autochthons, caused dissatisfaction among the latter. Attention is also drawn to the peculiar separatism of Sevryuks, who, during the Time of Troubles in Muscovy in the early XVIIth century, have given support to False Dmitrys, chieftain Bolotnikov and other impostors. To this, Moscow authorities responded with brutal terror, in the course of which the rebels were dealt with in the most terrible way. It resulted in devastation of Sivershchyna, while the remains of aboriginal population were assimilated. Conclusion. The comparison between Russia’s expansionist practices of today and five-to-three hundred years ago, including the great-power demagogy of Russian rulers, as justification for conquest, as well as the predatory behavior of Russian subjects, demonstrates a significant similarity. This indicates that the emergence of the current ideology of Rashism and Rashist practices goes back to old times, when the future Russian Empire just began to come into being.

Keywords

Siverian Lands, conquest, ethnic cleansing, terror, Rashism.

References

1. HRYHOROVYCH, Ivan (compiler-editor). Acts Relating to the History of Western Russia, Collected and Published by the Archaeographic Commission. Saint Petersburg: Printing House of the IInd Department ofHis Imperial Majesty’s Personal Chancellery, 1846, vol. I, 432 pp. [in Russian].
2. ARUTYUNOV, Sergey. Peoples and Cultures: Their Development and Interaction. Moscow: Science, 1989, 247 pp. [in Russian].
3. BALUSHOK, Vasyl. Enigmatic Sevriuks: 5. The Name Problem. Territory and State of Its Occupancy. In: Volodymyr DIATLOV, ed.inchief, The Siverian Chronicle: A Scientific Journal, 2016, no. 6 (132), pp. 44–55 [in Ukrainian].
4. BALUSHOK, Vasyl. Peculiarities of Economic Activity of Sevryuks (XIVth to XVIIth Centuries). In: Hanna SKRYPNYK, ed.inchief, Folk Art and Ethnology, 2017, no. 4 (368), pp. 41–50 [in Ukrainian].
5. BALUSHOK, Vasyl. From the History of Ukrainian Ethnonymy (from “Ruthenians” to “Ukrainians”). In: Valeriy SMOLIY, ed.inchief, The Ukrainian Historical Journal. Kyiv: Scientific Thought, 2018, no. 2 (539), pp. 163–178 [in Ukrainian]. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15407/uhj2018.02.163.
6. BUSSOW, Conrad. The Muscovite Chronicle, Containing Matters from the Death of Ivan Vasilyevich the Tyrant, the Most Ferocious and Savage of All Whom the Sun Saw after Their Births, in the Year of Christ 1584–1612. In: Conrad BUSSOW, Arsenios of Elassonos, Elias HERCKMANS. Chronicles of the Time of Troubles: The History of Russia and the House of Romanov in the Memoirs of Contemporaries of the XVIIth–XXth Centuries. Moscow: Sergey Dubov Foundation, 1998, pp. 11–158 [in Russian].
7. VESELOVSKY, Stepan. Onomasticon. Ancient Rus’s Names, Nicknames, and Surnames. Moscow: Science, 1974, 382 pp. [online]. Available from: http://www.pseudology.org/state/Onomastikon2.pdf (accessed on July 31, 2020) [in Russian].
8. GUREVICH, Aron. Categories of the Medieval Culture. Second edition. Moscow: Art, 1984, 350 pp. [in Russian].
9. BUDZIŁŁO, Józef. A Diary of Events Relating to the Time of Troubles (1603–1613), Known as the History of False Dmitry. In: Mikhail KOYALOVICH, ed., The Russian Historical Library. Saint Petersburg, 1872, vol. 1, pp. 84–364 [in Russian].
10. ISAIEVYCH, Yaroslav. Ancient and New Ukraine: Its People, Religion, and Culture. Lviv: NASU’s Ivan Krypyakevych Institute of Ukrainian Studies, 1996, 334 pp. [in Ukrainian].
11. KOLESNITSKY, Nikolay. Pre-National Ethnic Communities (Based on Materials from Medieval Germany). In: Races and Peoples: An Annual. Moscow: Science, 1978, iss. 8, pp. 21–46 [in Russian].
12. CONTAMINE, Philippe. War in the Middle Ages. Translated from French by Yuriy MALININ et al. Saint Petersburg: Juventa, 2001, 416 pp. [in Russian].
13. KRAVCHENKO, Volodymyr. Kharkov/Kharkiv: A Capital of the Borderlands. Vilnius: European Humanities University, 2010, 358 pp. [in Russian].
14. KULAKOVSKYI, Petro. The Role and Significance of Putyvl in the Smolensk War of 1632–1634 [online]. Available from: http://putivl-zapovidnyk.org/vidannja/rol-i-znachennja-putivlja-v-smolenskij-vijni-1632-1634-rr.php (accessed on July 11, 2021) [in Ukrainian].
15. LAZAREVSKY, Aleksandr. A Description of Old Lesser Russia. Vol. 1: Starodub Regiment. Kiev: Printing House of K. N. Milevsky, 1888, 522 pp. [in Russian].
16. LEVSHUN, Lubov. The «Litvins» Concept in the Ethno-Cultural Identity of Belarusians. In: Vadzim HIHIN, ed.inchief, The Belarusian Thought, 2009, no. 11, pp. 102–109 [in Russian].
17. The Metrica of the Grand Duchy of Lithuania, section I, part I: Book of Records, vol. I. In: Ivan LAPPO, ed., The Russian Historical Library. Saint Petersburg: Edition of the Archaeographic Commission, 1910, vol. 27, IX + 38 + 150 pp. [in Russian].
18. MASSA, Isaac. A Brief Notice on the Beginnings and Origins of Modern Wars and Distempers in Muscovy, Which Occurred before 1610 during Short Reigns of Several Sovereigns. In: Isaac MASSA, Peter PETREIUS. On the Beginnings of Wars and Unrests in Muscovy. Compiled and edited by Aleksandr LIBERMANN. Moscow: Rita-Print, 1997, pp. 13–150 [in Russian].
19. The Complete Collection of Russian Chronicles. Saint Petersburg: Printing House of Eduard Pratz, 1859, vol. 8: Continuation of the Resurrection List Chronicle (ed. by Afanasy BYCHKOV), 302 pp. [in Russian].
20. The Complete Collection of Russian Chronicles. Petrograd: 2nd State Printing House, 1921, vol. 24: The Typographic Chronicle (edited by Aleksey SHAKHMATOV, Aleksandr PRESNYAKOV; compiled by Sergey ROZANOV), [3] + 271 pp. [in Russian].
21. The Complete Collection of Russian Chronicles. Moscow: Science, 1978, vol. 34: The Postnikov, Piskaryov, Moscow, and Belaya Chroniclers (edited by Viktor BUGANOV and Vadim KORETSKY), 304 pp. [in Russian].
22. RAKITIN, Anton. Sevryuks, An Indigenous Population of the Severian Lands [online]. Available from: http://sivertsi-siver.narod.ru/sevruki.htm (accessed on August 11, 2019) [in Russian].
23. RUSYNA, Olena. The Severian Lands within the Grand Duchy of Lithuania. Kyiv: NASU’s Institute of Ukrainian Archeography and Source Studies, 1998, 244 pp. [in Ukrainian].
24. KARPOV, Gennady, ed. The Collection of the Imperial Russian Historical Society. Saint Petersburg: Printing House of F. Eleonski, 1882, vol. 35, pt. 1, VI, XXII, 870 pp., 116 col. [in Russian].
25. BELOKUROV, Sergey, ed. The Collection of the Imperial Russian Historical Society. Saint Petersburg: Printing House G. Lissner and D. Sobko, 1912, vol. 137, XX, 809 pp. [in Russian].
26. SMITH, Anthony D. National Identity. Translated from English by Petro TARASHCHUK. Kyiv: Solomiya Pavlychko’s Publishers Osnovy, 1994, 224 pp. [in Ukrainian].
27. TEMUSHEV, Victor. The First Moscow-Lithuanian Border War 1486–1494. Moscow: Quadriga, 2013, 239 pp. [in Russian].
28. TOLOCHKO, Oleksii. The Image of «Foreigner» in the Worldview of Pre-Mongol Rus. In: Oleksii TOLOCHKO, secretaryinchief, Mediaevalia Ucrainica: Mentality and History of Ideas. Kyiv: NASU’s Institute of Ukrainian Archeography and Source Studies, 1992, vol. I, pp. 26–46 [in Ukrainian].
29. TUPIKOV, Nikolay. A Dictionary of Ancient Rus’s Personal Proper Names. Saint Petersburg: Printing House of I. N. Skorokhodov, 1903, 904 pp. [in Russian].
30. FILARET (GUMILEVSKY, Dmitry). The Historical and Statistical Description of the Chernihiv Eparchy. Chernihiv: Zemstvo’s Printing House, 1874, bk. 6: Novhorod-Siverskyi, Sosnytsia, Horodnia,, Konotop, and Borzna Districts, 438 pp. [in Russian].
31. The Bykhovets Chronicle. Edited by Nikolay TIKHOMIROV; prefaced, annotated and translated from Ruthenian by Mikałaj UŁAŠČYK. Moscow: Science, 1966, 155 pp. [in Russian].
32. CHIZHIKOVA, Ludmila. Russian-Ukrainian Borderlands: History and Destinies of Traditional Everyday Culture. Edited by Kirill CHISTOV. USSR Academy of Sciences’ Nikolay Miklouho-Maclay Institute of Ethnography. Moscow: Science, 1988, 256 pp. [in Russian].
33. YAVORNYTSKYI, Dmytro. The History of Zaporizhzhian Cossacks: in 3 Volumes. Edited by Pavlo SOKHAN (editorial board’s chairperson) et al. Kyiv: Scientific Thought, 1991, vol. 3, 557 pp. [in Russian & Ukrainian].
34. YAKOVENKO, Natalia. An Outline of the History of Ukraine from the Earliest Times to the Late 18th Century. Kyiv: Genesis, 1997, 380 pp. [in Ukrainian].
35. YAKOVENKO, Natalia. The Parallel World. Studies on the History of Conceptions and Ideas in Ukraine in the XVIth–XVIIth Centuries. Kyiv: Criticism, 2002, 416 pp. [in Ukrainian].
36. KUCZYŃSKI, Stefan Maria. The Chernihiv-Severian Lands under the Rule of Lithuania. Warsaw, 1936, 420 pp. [in Polish].
37. POHL, Walter. Political uses of Ethnicity in early medieval Europe. In: The University of Cologne Forum «Ethnicity as a Political Resource» (ed.). Ethnicity as a Political Resource: Conceptualizations across Disciplines, Regions, and Periods. Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag, 2015, pp. 201–208 [in English]. DOI: https://doi.org/10.14361/9783839430132-015.
38. STAGL, Justin. Cultural Anthropology and Eurocentrism. In: René PUSCH, ed., Viennese Ethnological Communications. Vienna: Austrian Ethnological Society, 1986, vol. 28, pp. 33–66 [in German].